Kefir vs Milk: Which Is Less Inflammatory?

Kefir

Kefir

LOW
Inflammation Score 3/10
Winner
VS
Milk

Milk

MEDIUM
Inflammation Score 5/10

Kefir is less inflammatory than milk, by two points: kefir sits at the low end of the inflammation scale and milk in the middle. Kefir is milk with live cultures added and left to ferment, so this is one food at two stages rather than two different ones, and it pours on cereal or into a glass just the same.

Fermenting uses up most of the lactose, the milk sugar that most adults worldwide lose the ability to digest, which is why milk leaves so many people bloated and crampy and kefir does not. Kefir also holds a wider mix of live bacteria and yeasts than yogurt. Adults who drank a glass a day for six weeks reported fewer digestive symptoms, and kefir made with traditional kefir grains brought inflammation signals down.

Milk on its own did not raise the inflammation markers a doctor measures in the feeding trials, and a cup covers around a third of the day’s calcium. It sits in the middle of the scale because of how many people react to it: lactose troubles most adults, and milk protein is a common trigger in autoimmune conditions, eczema and acne. Fermenting leaves that protein intact, so kefir fixes the lactose problem and not the protein one. If lactose is what bothers you, pour plain kefir on your cereal this week instead of milk, and buy the unsweetened bottle, because flavoured kefir can hold as much sugar as a soft drink.

Side by side

KefirMilk
Inflammation ScoreLow · 3/10Medium · 5/10
CategoryDairyDairy
Serving size1 cup (240 ml) plain, unsweetened1 cup (240 ml)
Key nutrientsLive cultures (L. kefiri), Kefir yeasts, Calcium, Vitamin B12Calcium, Vitamin B12, Lactose, Saturated fat
How oftenA glass a day, plain and unsweetenedUp to 1 cup a day if it agrees with you

On the AIP diet

Not allowed

Kefir

The Autoimmune Protocol pulls every dairy product during the elimination phase, and fermenting the milk does not exempt kefir. Milk protein comes through fermentation intact, and it is a common trigger in autoimmune conditions. Water kefir and coconut kefir are the usual stand-ins, since the grains ferment sugar water or coconut milk just as well. Dairy kefir is a reasonable thing to try first when dairy is reintroduced later.

Not allowed

Milk

Milk is not allowed on the Autoimmune Protocol. AIP removes every form of dairy during the elimination phase, and milk is the clearest case, because it carries both the lactose and the milk proteins that tend to keep symptoms going. Dairy is one of the last groups reintroduced, and that normally starts with ghee rather than a glass of milk. For coffee, unsweetened coconut milk is the usual stand-in.

What each one brings

Kefir

  • Carries a wider mix of live bacteria and yeasts than yogurt does
  • Fermentation removes most of the lactose, so it sits easier than milk
  • Eased digestive symptoms in adults who drank a glass a day for six weeks
  • Made with traditional kefir grains, it brought inflammation signals down

Milk

  • One cup covers around a third of the day's calcium, and most adults fall short
  • One of the few everyday foods bringing calcium, vitamin B12 and iodine in the same glass
  • Across the feeding trials, milk did not raise the inflammation markers a doctor measures
  • Cheap, filling protein that needs no preparation at all

Watch out for

Kefir

  • Milk protein survives fermentation, so dairy reactions stay the same
  • Flavoured bottles can hold as much sugar as a soft drink
  • Many supermarket kefirs are made without the traditional grain organisms
  • A full glass can loosen the stomach in the first few days

Milk

  • Most adults worldwide lose the ability to digest lactose properly, and for them milk means bloating and cramps
  • Milk protein is a common trigger in autoimmune conditions, eczema and acne
  • Flavoured milk, milkshakes and sweetened coffee drinks are mostly sugar, which is a different food
  • Whole milk adds up in saturated fat if you drink several glasses a day

Get the inflammation score of any meal

Just snap a photo or describe your food to get its inflammation score and uncover hidden patterns that may be affecting your well-being.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
InflammaScan app

Learn more about each food